We lie to children. One of these lies is,

Work hard to get ahead.

The sentiment here is that if you work hard then you will reap the rewards. However, this just isn’t how the world works. I’d like to illustrate what I mean with a hypothetical story, a parable, about our protagonist, Bob.

Bob

Bob has worked hard all his life - in school, university and then in his job. In each of these areas he is a high achiever. He sacrificed his personal time to do the best possible - to always have his assignments in, to do the best of every presentation and every project. And is good at it. In each of them he excels. He sacrifices mean that his work always goes above and beyond.

Bob will always have a job. There’s always going to be someone willing to employ someone who works his butt off, and so Bob is always able to earn money. To that extent the adage is true. He has got ahead. But Bob also attracts Eve.

Eve is the opposite of Bob. Her skill in life is to claim credit (or deny blame) for others’ work. And when Eve meets Bob she has struck an absolute goldmine - a constant source of excellent work which she can exploit. Eve uses her skills to present Bob’s hard work as if it was her own.

A constant topic of Eve’s conversation is all the amazing work that she has apparently done, but without any mention of Bob. When Bob talks to others he is puzzled that they seem to know about the work he’s doing, but surprised they don’t know he has anything at all to do with it. But Bob is busy and so it just seems odd. But it’s a successful strategy for Eve, who is promoted to a position above Bob, for her consistently excellent work.

As a superior, Eve gets to report what work everyone under her is doing, including Bob. Eve openly talks about all the work as if it is her work alone. Bob rationalises this to himself as when she says that “she” did it, everyone understands it’s her team. But in official reports things are worse. All the reporting goes through Eve, so Bob doesn’t even see when she puts her own name down on Bob’s projects. Bob is not mentioned as having anything to do with many of them at all - or if he is mentioned, he’s put down as responsible for a very small fraction, at most 20% or 30% of his actual contribution.

It looks to those higher up, as if Bob’s workload is a tiny fraction of what he’s actually doing. That’s bad for two reasons. First, he’s not being acknowledged for the things he is achieving. Secondly, to every superior except Eve, it looks like Bob is not actually busy. So, every time there’s a new project or task, it is assigned to Bob. Bob’s responsibilities continually expand: 80, 90, even 100 hours per week, with nobody outside the team aware. But Bob thinks that if he works hard, he’ll get ahead, so he keeps going, dutifully believing his work is appreciated. Eventually even Bob starts to burn out.

But what can Bob do? It’s hard for him to cut down, because he’s not officially doing any of the work he is actually doing. When he goes to HR, they flatly insist that, no, he’s not actually even involved in the projects which he’s been working on for the last five years.

By this time, Bob has been working in a position way above his pay grade for many years. If he quit, he’d be back a decade of work, leaving behind the castles that he’s nurtured and built, applying for positions well below the level he’s actually been working at (even if that’s unacknowledged). In fact, he can’t even talk about the work he’s been doing for a significant fraction of his life, or it will be contradicted by the official record and Eve. And by this point Eve is telling him point blank not to talk about all the work he’s done. After all it’s far in excess of what anyone ‘should’ have done - and he doesn’t want to be in trouble for violating company policy or the workplace regulations. So Bob continues.

In the end it isnt the level of the level of physical work that gets to Bob, it is his inner life. Bob is older now, and working such long working weeks (and weekends) is physically taking its toll. But what grates to Bob is struggling to cope mentally. He is doing work today that tomorrow Alice will claim she did, and he knows it. He knows he won’t be able to say tomorrow what he did today. He’s living a shadow of a real life - where he almost doesn’t exist. Bob regrets all the sacrifice that he’s made- all that hard work over many years- for others gain.

I don’t know what became of Bob, but he certainly no longer believes in working hard to get ahead. He spent his life doing that, and wishes that someone had warned him when he was young, that it doesn’t necessarily follow.

Bob’s case is just a story. But in my observation, in any sizeable organisation, whether it’s government or private, if it’s big enough, there will always a large number of ‘Eves’: People who are better at climbing the greasy pole than actually providing anything of value; People who are not constrained to act in moral ways, such as accurately attributing work, if that gets in the way of their own advancement; People who are better at taking credit for a task, than doing the task in the first place.

I wish it wasn’t that way, but that is the way our world is.