In support of self-determination
“What type of peace do we seek? Not a Pax-Americana, enforced on the world by the weapons of war. Not the peace of the grave, or the security of the slave. I am talking about genuine peace. The type of peace that makes life on earth worth living. The kind of peace that allows men and nations to grow, and to hope, and build a better life for their children. Not merely peace for Americans, but peace for all men and women. Not merely peace in our time, but peace in all time.” - John F. Kennedy.
![]()
Nearly eighty years ago, in the aftermath of the most gruesome, cruelest and most deadly conflict in human history, the world’s powers created a vision for global stability and justice. The United States and the Soviet Union championed a rules-based international order. This framework was enshrined in documents like the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the UN charter. Unlike the colonial systems or the Treaty of Versailles, the post-WWII was not system didn’t unfairly benefit the victors, but was one which aimed to treat every nation fairly. In so doing, the authors hoped, it woul prevent the horrors their generation had just experienced in war and foster a world where every nation could thrive in peace.
Today, the idealism of that time is gone, and the memory of war has faded. This international system is today referred to “rules-based international order”, and it is under attack. Leaders like Vladimir Putin of Russia decry it as a tool of the United States, colonialism, and say it is opposed to a multi-polar world. At home in the West, nationalists question its relevance where it can often seem to a nation’s advantage to pursue their own self-interest, even if that comes at a cost to the international community or cooperation. Brexit is an obvious example of these types of arguments.
I do not believe these criticisms are correct. Although I would be the first to say the system has not always been perfect, I believe in the values and ideals expressed by our grandparents. These ideals are worth defending and strengthening, regardless of which side of the Pacific we come from. It’s a huge topic, but in this small blog post, I’d like to talk about just one of the principles of the rules-based international order- the principle of self determination.
A typical example of recent criticism of this principle comes from Putin and hitting out at criticism of his miliary aggression against Ukraine. To set the scene: Putin believes that historically Ukraine is a part of Russia. He writes that he believes that Ukrainians and Belorussians are actually ethnically Russian, and that when the Soviet Union disintegrated the borders hould have reverted to what they were before 1921. At that time Ukraine didn’t exist as an independent country. Putin’s view would effectively cede Ukraine to Russia.
Putin’s primary problem is that, this is clearly the opposite of what the Ukrainian people actually want. The people of Ukraine have themselves demonstrated this. First, they demonstrated it with a democratic vote in which they expressed the desire to work towards becoming a part of the EU, rejecting Russia. Secondly Ukraine has fought heroically against Russian occupation showing unbelievable resistance in the face of seemingly overwhelming odds. Ukraine has now resisted nearly two and half years against one of the world’s largest militaries.
Ukrainian grandmothers made this point more eloquently that I could:
What the f— are you doing on our land with all these guns? Take these seeds and put them in your pockets, so at least sunflowers will grow when you all lie down here
Or the Ukrainians on Snake Island,
Russian warship: “Snake Island, I, Russian warship, repeat the offer: put down your arms and surrender, or you will be bombed. Have you understood me? Do you copy?”
Ukrainian: “Russian warship, go fuck yourself.”
The Ukrainian people have spoken clearly. They clearly do not want to incorporated into Russia, putting them at direct odds with Putin’s view.
Article 1, Chapter 1 of the UN Charter, originally agreed to by Russia, China and the United States along with 50 signatories, and today seen and formally accepted by almost every nation on earth, agrees to:
To develop friendly relations among nations based on respect for the principle of equal rights and self-determination of peoples, and to take other appropriate measures to strengthen universal peace
The more recent International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, ratified by 174 different countries (not including China or North Korea) agrees that
All peoples have the right of self-determination. By virtue of that right they freely determine their political status and freely pursue their economic, social and cultural development.
The right of self-determination gives people everywhere to have control over their own destiny, and to decide for themselves which country they want to be a part of. The test of whether Ukraine is independent or not, under the rules-based system, is not what Putin says, but what the Ukrainian people say. It is not whether or not the Russian people will be better off if they invade their neighbour. It is not whether Putin can make a questionable historical argument. Under the rules-based system the relevant question we should be asking is: What do the people of Ukraine want?
Faced with such a clear violation of long established principles, Putin has no choice but to condemn or muddy the principles themselves. Speaking at the recent BRICS summit, he said this:
Acting contrary to historical logic and often even to the detriment of the long-term interests of their own peoples, they are now seeking to establish some kind of order based on their so-called rules, which no one has seen, no one has discussed and no one has ever accepted. These rules are written and adjusted anew for each situation in the interests of those who consider themselves exceptional and have conferred on themselves the right to dictate their will to others. It’s exactly in the best traditions of colonialism.
On the contrary, the rules-based international order saw the dismantling of colonialism across the world. Far from being opposed to a multipolar world, the rules-based system set up exactly that, in contrast to a system of nationalism, where by the early 1900’s the strongest- namely the European powers- had divided the world among themselves. The period from 1945 to 1960 saw some 36 Asian and African countries become independent of the their previous colonial rulers. This includes India, and countries from Indonesia to Korea. The US did not confer on themselves different rights than they insisted of others, instead, the US volutarily gave up control of the countries which they had conquered in WW2 and granted the Phillipines its independence in 1946.
This is not a rule arbitrarily dictated to by the countries of the world by the US, but one which has remained for almost 80 years and is amost univerally ratified and endorsed. Countries around the world haven’t signed up for this because of US pressure, but because it is good for us, the people who come from the less powerful nations in the world. It’s good to be able to determine our own fate, and not have that imposed by colonial or imperialist powers. International acceptance to this policy protects us, stripping the legitimacy from any agressor, whether that’s the European powers of old, or Russia, or China or even if it was the US.
But it is not only the people in less powerful nations who benefit from a rules-based order, but the more powerful countries too. If Ukraine crumbled tomorrow, Russian soliders would be required to police an unwilling population. Russian soldiers that would still be mocked by grandmothers in the streets. Adherence would need to imposed by harsh measures, none of which would be cheap for Russia; not in terms of money, or reputation, or lives. The wounds would continue. The fragile peace might last fourty years, but eventually it would come crashing down. Self-interest imposed on others is not a basis for lasting peace.

Why choose the rules-based path of restraint over national self interest? To the post-WW2 generation, having seen the horrors of war, the answer was clear. The reason for the rules-based order is that that, unlike militarily imposed rule, the aim is a real, sustainable and just peace- beneficial for all- and not just a temporary pause plastered over by the increasing use of military power and social controls. Why should we all voluntarily limit our national power? We should do it because that leads to a lasting peace, which benefits us all. In a speech arguing for a nuclear test-ban treaty (which Khrushchev liked so much he ordered printed in Pravda), JFK put it like this:
For, in the final analysis, our most basic common link is that we all inhabit this small planet. We all breathe the same air. We all cherish our children’s future. And we are all mortal.
Berlin Wall photo by Aad van der Drift.